"I love you, Darcy. I love your spunk, love your humor, and love that you were so kind to me at a time when no one was. But Friend, I've unfriended you on FB and here's why. It seems most every time I post anything political or even the very mention of their names, you rant on my wall. I get it, you are unhappy about the election. But Darcy, I'm not unhappy about it. It saddens me that there's such a divide between us. And no amount of ranting will change it. I wish you all the best and I hope we can remain friends in real life."
Is being "unfriended" the same thing as losing a friend?
I've known Renee for almost two decades. We worked on the same crew together for a year, but we also spent a good part of our spare time together as well, laughing about nonsense, watching rom-coms, smoking, trading dating war stories. I taught her cat how to fetch. We shared a work "brother" - we'll call him Austin - and together we traveled, drank shots, cranked out sports TV. With me, she was wonderfully generous with her time, her good nature and humor, and her cheerful support.
With others, she wasn't always so easy; I ran interference for her several times - within our work group and eventually with the director - and I advocated for her fiercely, as you would, of course, for a dear friend. When a veteran freelancer shattered her confidence, I reassured her, recommended her to colleagues, and even contacted that freelancer before they worked together again, asking her to take Renee under her wing.
So.
Years later, Renee posted that Mike Pence was visiting her town and that she feared violence from protesters. I wished safety for her, the police, and the protesters. I also said that I would have joined the protest because Pence’s policies endangered gay and transgender people, including people I love.
That was the “rant” that got me unfriended.
I told Renee I wasn’t simply unhappy about an election. Pence had supported policies that could cost my loved ones their jobs, access to services, and physical safety. Fighting for people who are being bullied wasn’t a departure from the person she knew. It was the same instinct that had once made me fight for her.
Renee said she wanted Facebook to be a source of joy: friends, children, pets, and everyday life. Fair enough.
But she hadn’t posted a puppy. She had posted about a political event and her fear of protesters. I had responded with my fear for people threatened by the politician they were protesting.
She insisted her post wasn’t political. Her fears were her own, she said, and we didn’t have to fear the same things.
That was true. I didn’t need her to share my fear. I needed her to acknowledge it.
I had validated her fear, despite there being no violence. I repeatedly told her that I feared for the safety of people I loved, based on policies Pence had actually supported. Not once did she say, “I’m sorry you have to be afraid for them.”
That was when I finally understood we weren’t friends in real life, either.
Geography had merely allowed us to preserve the fiction. A friend doesn’t have to agree with you politically, but a friend should care when you say, plainly and repeatedly, “The people I love are provably in danger.”
Maybe Renee will someday understand that empathy isn’t agreement. It’s the willingness to recognize another person’s fear even when it disrupts your peaceful Facebook feed.
Or maybe she’ll simply decide I’m just an angry woman.
Anger seems like a reasonable response when someone values the appearance of kindness more than the practice of it.
